Cartridges for cowboy action shooting with RS14

The new RS14 from Nitrochemie Wimmis is a special powder with low bulk density and reduced energy content. It is also suitable for cartridges that were originally designed for black powder propellants – revolver and rifle cartridges with bulky cases (e.g. .45 Colt, .45-70 Government, etc.). These calibres are highly popular in cowboy action shooting, where there is a preference for loads with a low recoil.

These light loads are often achieved using a “traditional”, fast burning powder. The fact that only 30-50% of the useable case capacity is used means there are certain disadvantages. The low filling level means the shooting process is affected by the position of the powder inside the case. A double load is also possible – which would have catastrophic consequences for shooter and gun alike. The new RS14 is free from these disadvantages. The low bulk density and low energy content mean the filling level is always above 50%. Even a load with a 100% filling level (normally) remains below the permitted Pmax. A summary of the RS powders for handguns is provided in the table below:

RS14RS12RS20RS24
Bulk density
Energy content (Qex)
g/l
J/g
316
3208
616
4022
617
4098
825
4367
The guns used for the Vo measurement

The guns used for the Vo measurement

In 2022, the RS14 development process was completed, and the first test samples were issued to both sport shooters and ammunition manufacturers. The Old West Shooting Society Switzerland (OWSSS) also received a sample, and the society’s president and his colleagues put the new powder through its paces.

The new RS14 powder was tested in a number of different calibres and guns (revolvers, lever-action rifles). The clean combustion with light loads and the precision on the target were both impressive. Due to the lack of a gun chronograph, it was not possible to measure muzzle velocity during these tests. This measurement provides information about the uniformity of the load, and is also used for RS customer load data.

LabRadar measurement in Wimmis

LabRadar measurement in Wimmis

In order to determine the muzzle velocities, the president of the OWSSS was invited to come and shoot in Wimmis in November 2022. The tests were not performed on the Nitrochemie premises, but instead at the pistol shooting range in Wimmis. We would like to say a huge thank you to the Shooting Range Officer, Mr. Lehnherr, who assisted us during the tests and made the facility available to us. The muzzle velocity was measured by Jan Krcmar (RS team at Nitrochemie), using a LabRadar.

The measured velocities and associated QuickLOAD calculation are shown in the tables below (SD = standard deviation, diff. = difference between the measurement and the QuickLOAD calculation). For the sake of precision, the loads that were used were weighed individually.

Gun: Uberti 1873 Cattleman revolver

Barrel length: 5.5"

Calibre: .45 Long Colt

Case: Starline

Bullet: 260 gr lead bullet with plastic coating (bullet length 16.6 mm)

Cartridge length: 39.9 mm

Crimp LEE Factory Crimp

Primer: LP Murom

Load
gr
NumberV0
m/s
V0 min
m/s
V0 max
m/s
Extreme spread
m/s
SD
m/s
E0
J
7.010226217232154.1430
6.51022121722693.0411
6.010212207218113.1379
5.510206202214124.0357

QuickLOAD calculation

Load
gr
Filling level
%
V0
m/s
Diff.
m/s
Pmax
bar
7.0802251675
6.5742138592
6.06820111515
5.56318818445

Summary: .45 Colt in the revolver

  • Very good V0 extreme spread.
  • Fired cases are clean, no powder residue.
  • QuickLOAD calculation matches the measurement well.

Gun: Uberti Winchester 1873 lever-action rifle

Barrel length: 20"

Calibre: .45 Long Colt

Case: Starline

Bullet: H&N RN .452, 230 gr HS (round nose 1.5 mm flattened -> flat nose)

Cartridge length: 40.0 mm

Crimp LEE Factory Crimp

Primer: LP CCI 300

Load
gr
NumberV0
m/s
V0 min
m/s
V0 max
m/s
Extreme spread
m/s
SD
m/s
E0
J
5.310212202219176.0335

QuickLOAD calculation

Load
gr
Filling level
%
V0
m/s
Diff.
m/s
Pmax
bar
5.354247-35347

.45 Colt with H&N RN 230 gr HS bullets – round nose 1.5 mm flattened

Summary: .45 Colt in the lever-action rifle

  • Good V0 extreme spread.
  • Fired cases are clean, no powder residue. Nevertheless, a higher load is recommended (from 6 gr).
  • QuickLOAD calculation (V0) is higher than the measurement (the load is very low, so the bullet can be slowed down while it is still in the barrel).

Gun: Winchester 1892 lever-action rifle (original from 1914)

Barrel length: 20"

Calibre: .44-40 Winchester (.44 WCF)

Case: CBC

Bullet: 200 gr lead bullet (LEE mould, dia. 429 -200-RF calibrated to .427)

Cartridge length: 39.3 mm

Crimp LEE Factory Crimp

Primer: LP Winchester

Load
gr
NumberV0
m/s
V0 min
m/s
V0 max
m/s
Extreme spread
m/s
SD
m/s
E0
J
7.010321311326154.0668
6.51031230731472.6631
6.01029629229972.1568
5.5102772362955916.3497

QuickLOAD calculation

Loag
gr
Filling level
%
V0
m/s
Diff.
m/s
Pmax
bar
7.083322-1672
6.5773075588
6.0712933511
5.5652770441

6.5 gr RS14 load – good obturation, spent cases are clean

Summary: .44-40 Winchester

  • Very good V0 extreme spread from the 6.0 gr load upwards (5.5 gr load is too low).
  • Fired cases are clean (apart from the 5.5 gr load), no powder residue.
  • QuickLOAD calculation matches the measurement very well. 

Gun: Miroku Winchester 1886 lever-action rifle

Barrel length: 26"

Calibre: .45-70 Government

Case: Starline

Bullet: H&N TC 400 gr HS

Cartridge length: 63.9 mm

Crimp: Roll crimp

Primer: LR Murom KYB-7

Load
gr
NumberV0
m/s
V0 min
m/s
V0 max
m/s
Extreme spread
m/s
SD
m/s
E0
J
13.5431531331741.41286
15.65342335348135.31516

QuickLOAD calculation

Load
gr
Filling level
%
V0
m/s
Diff.
m/s
Pmax
bar
13.578321-61258
15.690347-51576

Summary: .45-70

  • Very good V0 extreme spread.
  • Fired cases are clean, no powder residue.
  • QuickLOAD calculation matches the measurement very well.

Gun: Uberti 1873 Cattleman revolver

Barrel length: 4.75"

Calibre: .357 Magnum

Case: PPU

Bullet: H&N RN 158 gr HS (1.5 mm round nose, flattened -> flat nose)

Cartridge length: 39.6 mm

Crimp: Roll crimp

Primer: SP Ginex SP

Load
gr
NumberV0
m/s
V0 min
m/s
V0 max
m/s
Extreme spread
m/s
SD
m/s
E0
J
4.010207195222278.6219

QuickLOAD calculation

Load
gr
Filling level
%
V0
m/s
Diff.
m/s
Pmax
bar
4.079208-1624

Summary: .357 Magnum

  • V0extreme spread only satisfactory. Note: The 4 gr RS14 load was also shot in other guns (and with other bullets), and the extreme spread was better.
  • Fired cases are clean, no powder residue.
  • QuickLOAD calculation matches the measurement very well.

Summary: Cowboy action shooting with RS14 cartridges

  • In general, there is a very good V0 difference, provided the load is not too low.
  • Although loads with a filling level of around 50 - 100% are possible, the best V0 extreme spread is (normally) achieved when the filling level is approximately 70 - 90%.
  • Fired cases are clean and there was no powder residue in the cases or the guns.
  • Charging in the powder device works well.
  • QuickLOAD calculations compared to the V0 measurements are in the good range.

Jan Krcmar

RS enthusiast

Privacy settings

We place great importance on transparent information relating to all aspects of data protection. Our website contains detailed information on the settings you can select and what effect these settings have. You can change your selected settings at any time. Regardless of the selection you choose, we will not draw any conclusions regarding you as a person (except where you have explicitly entered your details). For information on deleting the cookies, please see the help function in your browser. You can find out more in the data protection declaration.

Change your privacy settings by clicking on the corresponding buttons

Necessary

Cookies essential for the system ensure that the website works correctly. Without these cookies, malfunctions or error messages may occur.

This website will:

  • Store cookies required by the system
  • Store the settings you make on this website

This site will never do the following without your agreement:

  • Store your settings, such as the language selection or cookie banner, so that you do not have to repeat them in the future.
  • Evaluate visits anonymously and draw conclusions to help us to optimize our website.
  • Draw conclusions regarding you as a person (except where you have explicitly entered your details, e.g. in contact forms)

Convenience

These cookies make the website easier to use and save settings, for example, so that you do not have to repeat them every time you visit the site.

This website will:

  • Store cookies required by the system
  • Store your settings, such as the language selection or cookie banner, so that you do not have to repeat them in the future.

This site will never do the following without your agreement:

  • Evaluate visits anonymously and draw conclusions to help us to optimize our website.
  • Draw conclusions regarding you as a person (except where you have explicitly entered your details, e.g. in contact forms)

Statistics cookies enable us to evaluate the usage behaviour on the website anonymously – without enabling any conclusions to be drawn about you as a person. This enables us to measure the performance of the website and to improve it continuously to offer a better user experience.

This website will:

  • Store cookies required by the system
  • Draw conclusions regarding you as a person (except where you have explicitly entered your details, e.g. in contact forms)
  • Evaluate visits anonymously and draw conclusions to help us to optimize our website.

This site will never do the following without your agreement:

  • Draw conclusions regarding you as a person (except where you have explicitly entered your details, e.g. in contact forms)

Notice regarding data transfers to the USA

If you select "STATISTICS", cookies from the US-based company Google Inc. will also be used. By selecting this option, you also expressly agree in accordance with Art. 49 Para. 1 S. 1 lit. a GDPR that your data collected by these cookies can also be processed by Google in the USA. The European Court of Justice (ECJ) has qualified the USA as a country with a level of data protection inadequate to EU standards. Further information on Google's handling of data protection can be found here.


Of course, we will always respect the do-not-track (DNT) setting in your browser. In this case, no tracking cookies are set and no tracking functions are loaded.